One in a Million

Released

Aaliyah’s sophomore release was a breakthrough for the simple yet hard-to-perfect reason that she was not only assured beyond her years as a singer — more concerned with emotional nuance than melismatic acrobatics — but capable of commanding any R&B subgenre that was thrown at her. Diane Warren ballads (“The One I Gave My Heart To”), Treach-hooked boom-bap/g-funk hybrids (“A Girl Like You”), trans-generational throwback nods to hitmaker-slash-auteur predecessors (Marvin on “Got to Give It Up”; the Isleys on “Choosey Lover (Old School/New School)”) — it’s your classic teenaged phase-shifting identity search, except it’s one that reveals how valid all those phases’ paths could be. The most promising path, of course, was the one with writer/producers Missy Elliott and Timbaland, who peak early with the title cut by giving her a distinctively eccentric take on club-steeped, trip-hop-adjacent production (that cricket loop!). Further single pulls like the neo-soul/trip-hop hybrid “Hot Like Fire,” the gelatinous funk of “If Your Girl Only Knew,” and the no-frills slow jam “4 Page Letter” don’t hint quite as clearly towards the staggering innovation of subsequent collabs like “Are You That Somebody” or “We Need a Resolution,” but they still sound like the album’s future-focused heart, and smartly foreground Aaliyah’s vocal depth in a way that makes them feel utterly complete — and those later classics predestined.

Nate Patrin

Suggestions
Between the Sheets cover

Between the Sheets

The Isley Brothers
Branded cover

Branded

Isaac Hayes
Back to Black cover

Back to Black

Amy Winehouse
The Art of War cover

The Art of War

Bone Thugs-n-Harmony
Supa Dupa Fly cover

Supa Dupa Fly

Missy Elliott
Emotions cover

Emotions

Mariah Carey
A Musical Affair cover

A Musical Affair

Ashford & Simpson
Donuts cover

Donuts

J Dilla
The Tour cover

The Tour

Mary J. Blige